Atek MIYU
The proposed Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP), declared a National Project by the Government of India in 2008, has become an issue of extensive public debates and discussions in Arunachal Pradesh, and throughout the nation. Families who may be affected are particularly concerned about losing their ancestral lands and being displaced from the settlements that have sustained them for generations. For these communities, land is not merely an economic asset. It represents their shared history, identity, cultural heritage, social relationships and connection with their ancestors. Understandably, the uncertainty surrounding the project has caused considerable emotional distress and anxiety.
Why Is SUMP a Matter of National Importance?
As highlighted in the earlier articles of this series, the Siang is part of a transboundary river system connecting three countries: China, India and Bangladesh. The river originates in Tibet as the Yarlung Tsangpo. According to the Central Water Commission (CWC), the Yarlung Tsangpo reportedly contributes approximately 84% of the Siang River's discharge during winter and about 65% of its average annual yield in Arunachal Pradesh.
China's Medog hydropower project, with an estimated storage of about 5.5 billion cubic metres (BCM), and the possibility of water being diverted towards northern China are therefore matters of serious concern for India. These concerns are heightened by the absence of a comprehensive water-sharing treaty between India and China and the expiry in June 2023 of the arrangement for sharing flood-season river data.
Against this background, SUMP has been proposed mainly to address water security, flood moderation and strategic concerns arising from upstream developments, with electricity generation as an additional benefit.
Political Narratives and the Need for Accurate Information
The project is presently in the Pre-Feasibility Report (PFR) stage, a short-term study to assess technical and financial viability of the SUMP. The PFR study has not progressed as expected, partly because several political parties, organisations and individuals from various districts and communities have perhaps confused the PFR with construction of the dam, without even accounting for Constitutional and legal safeguards which mandate extensive public consultations and public consent prior to any decision on dam construction.
In a democratic country, public participation is a fundamental right. Every individual and organisation is free to support, oppose or question the proposed project. However, some of the information in circulation does not reflect ground realities and may cause unnecessary fear among affected families. Unverified claims and exaggerated figures shared on social media often highlight only possible negative impacts, without explaining the project's objectives or potential benefits.
It is also important to remember that if a major flood or other emergency occurs, its consequences will be borne by the people living along the Siang River. Their safety and welfare must therefore remain at the centre of the discussion.
Some have also argued that the Siang dam controversy has continued for many years. However, earlier hydropower proposals must be distinguished from the present SUMP proposal, and the objectives and circumstances of each should be examined separately.
It may be noted that China has not shared any information regarding the Medog dam with India, despite multiple requests made by the Government of India, including at the level of the Minister of External Affairs.
This raises an important question. Considerable attention is being given to the possible adverse impacts of SUMP. Why are the potential risks to downstream areas from China's upstream hydropower project not receiving equal attention?
Common Misconception: How Can the 11,200 MW SUMP Counter China's 60,000 MW Hydropower Project?
A common question raised is how the proposed 11,200 MW SUMP could address the potential impacts of China's much larger 60,000 MW hydropower project. To answer this, it is important to distinguish between electricity generation capacity and water storage capacity.
Electricity generation capacity depends mainly on the volume of water flowing through the turbines (discharge) and the height from which the water falls (hydraulic head). The Medog project is expected to use a vertical drop of about 2,000 metres, giving it a combined installed capacity of around 60,000 MW. SUMP would operate with a much lower hydraulic head and therefore have a lower installed capacity of about 11,200 MW, even though it uses water from the same river.
Storage capacity, however, is a different matter. SUMP is expected to have a reservoir of about 9.2 BCM, which is 1.7 times larger than the Medog. In the event of sudden floods or release or diversion of water upstream, the excess water could be stored and released downstream in a controlled manner. It is this storage capacity, not the generating capacity, that matters for downstream safety and water security.
SUMP, the Adi Community and Likely Affected Families
For the Adi community, the Siang River is closely connected with everyday life, livelihoods, cultural traditions and a shared sense of identity. Any discussion on the future of the river must therefore be approached with sensitivity and respect.
At the same time, the Siang originates in Tibet, and as the upstream country, China is in a position to control the flow of the river within its territory. Any future diversion of water, sharp reduction in flow or change in the river's natural pattern could seriously affect the ecological, cultural and economic value of the Siang for the Adi community. This is a risk the Adi people must carefully weigh when considering the future of the river, whether or not SUMP is ultimately built.
A proper study of possible submergence and displacement is therefore essential. The number of villages, the extent of agricultural land and the other properties that may be affected can be determined only through the PFR and subsequent detailed investigations.
It is here that the primary challenge lies. Multiple social media commentators, for reasons best known to them, have shared figures of potential displacement of people and villages. This despite it being clear that no decision on probable locations for the SUMP can be made without completion of PFR, leave alone potential effects on land and properties. Such speculative and inaccurate information or rather misinformation, amplified by the certain individuals and organizations, creates a self-perpetuating cycle of falsehoods and fear, while making frank and free dialogue and discussions almost impossible.
Facts, Dialogue and Collective Responsibility
Public participation is legitimate and necessary. Citizens are free to question the project, examine government decisions and express opposition. However, public discussion should be based on accurate information and credible evidence, and personal attacks and allegations without evidence should be avoided. Rather than dividing communities, the discussion should focus on the real concerns of affected families, the potential benefits and risks of the project, and the alternatives available.
Equally, the government and concerned agencies have a responsibility to ensure that affected communities receive clear and complete information about the project, its objectives, its possible impacts and the measures being considered to protect their interests.
Constructive dialogue, scientific assessment and shared responsibility are essential for reaching informed decisions that protect both the rights of affected communities and the wider interests of the State and the nation.
An Informed Decision for the Future
SUMP is not merely a question of building a dam. It concerns water security, downstream safety, energy development, environmental protection, cultural identity and the future of the Adi communities living along the Siang.
The concerns of affected families deserve respect, especially when ancestral lands, livelihoods and heritage may be affected. At the same time, the implications of upstream developments in China and the need for effective river management cannot be ignored.
The central question should not simply be whether one supports or opposes SUMP. Rather, it should be how best to protect the people of the Siang Valley from future risks while safeguarding their long-term interests.
Whatever decision is ultimately taken should be guided by scientific and technical assessment, transparent public consultation, respect for local communities and a lasting commitment to the safety and welfare of people, while keeping in mind the water security and strategic interests of the Adi community, Arunachal Pradesh and the nation.
(This is the third part of a series of articles on the Siang Upper Multipurpose Project. The author is retired Chief Engineer, Department of Hydro Power Development. Views expressed are personal.)